Conditional UseRecommended denial (Mar 2026) · Council outcome not on record5305 and 5321 Monroe Street and 4700 Nantucket Drive

Sheetz Gas Station Development

Toledo

Description

A special use permit request to construct a Sheetz restaurant, convenience store, and fueling station operating 24 hours a day.

Impact summary

Generated substantial resident opposition over traffic and safety, resulting in a 2-2 tie vote and negative recommendation.

Applicant

Name: Alex Sawicki
Address: 5305 and 5321 Monroe Street and 4700 Nantucket Drive

At a glance

Hearings: 2
Public comments: 0
Total mentions: 2

Last vote

Recommended denial (Mar 2026) · Council outcome not on record2–2

A recommendation. The council’s outcome is not on record here.

Last discussed Mar 12, 2026.

Meeting timeline (2)

Mar 12, 2026Recommended denial 2–2

Toledo City Plan Commission - Mar 12, 2026

A special use permit application for a new Sheetz gas station and fuel sales facility with 24-hour operations.

Jan 15, 2026Tabled

Toledo City Plan Commission - Jan 15, 2026

A special use permit request to construct a Sheetz restaurant, convenience store, and fueling station operating 24 hours a day.

Related issues (1)

Proposed Sheetz Gas Station Development on Monroe Street

Residents raised major concerns about cut-through traffic, pedestrian safety without sidewalks, and neighborhood character regarding a proposed Sheetz gas station. The commission ultimately deadlocked and forwarded the project to council with a negative recommendation.

We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda, when it's voted on and when its status changes, at most once a day.

The weekly brief for Toledo

What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.

Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.